October 29, 2024
Food & Drink, Guides,
Whether you're looking for a spicy pumpkin pie in the fall, an apple pie a la mode in the summer, a savory pie for lunch or a chocolate pie as a fun alternative to birthday cake, it's always a good time to put pie on the menu.
We asked our editors across the country to name their best bakeries and favorite pies, and below, we've gathered the best of the best. From coast to coast and in between, here are the best pies in the country.
See also: 19 of the Best Coffee Shops Across America
Austin - Quack’s 43 Street Bakery
View this post on Instagram
411 E 43rd St., 512-453-3399 / Website
The name is funny, but the menu is seriously good! This from-scratch bakery first opened in 1983 and serves top-tier coffee. Besides rotational seasonal options, the good folks of Quack's always offer cherry pie, apple cinnamon, chocolate cream or coconut cream pie, plus a key lime tart. Don't stop there, because there are even more tasty treats on Austin's full list.
Chicago - Bang Bang Pie & Biscuits
View this post on Instagram
With innovative, inspired pie flavors like German chocolate, zesty Key lime and gluten-free chocolate caramel, this Logan Square mainstay makes homemade, Midwestern-inspired dishes, desserts and biscuits. Visitors can also sample savory pies such as the chicken pot pie with chicken gravy, carrots and peas and the Southern tomato pie with tomatoes, caramelized onions, basil and creamy cheddar cheese—each with a golden and flaky, all-butter pastry crust. Save room for later, because there are other great pie shops to check out on Chicago's full list.
Hamptons - Tate’s Bake Shop
View this post on Instagram
A Hamptons gem and a hosting gift emporium to many, Tate’s Bake Shop located in Southampton is the best bake shop in town for more reasons than one. Since 1980, Tate’s has delivered the best pies and confectionary desserts thanks to founder Kathleen King’s passion for baking. While you can buy them in almost every supermarket today, this famous Bake Shop is where the magic begins. Open seven days a week from 7 a.m. to 3 p.m., Tate’s is the place for the ultimate pecan or chocolate pie. Try even more fine flavors at one of the other bakeries on the Hampton's full list.
Las Vegas - Pies Unlimited
View this post on Instagram
This shop really lives up to its name. Serving more 30 flavors of fruit pies, cream pies, seasonal pies, specialty pies and meringue pies, it's the kind of place you come to all year long. Fall in love with German Chocolate Meringue, get in the winter spirit with Eggnog Cream, or come back in summer with Mango Cream and Pineapple. Strike gold by trying even more pies on Las Vegas' full list.
Los Angeles - The Apple Pan
View this post on Instagram
10801 W Pico Blvd / Website
This classic diner has been serving up pies since 1947. As one might guess, The Apple Pan’s apple pie is legendary, made with fresh apples and a flaky crust that will leave you wanting more. However, you’ll also delight in the full lineup with options like coconut cream, pecan and boysenberry. The city of stars has even more great pies to try on its full list.
Miami - Fireman Derek’s
View this post on Instagram
Multiple locations / Website
Fireman Derek’s coconut cream custard pie is a tropical dream come true. This indulgent dessert features a silky coconut custard, rich in flavor and perfectly balanced with a light sweetness. It’s generously topped with fluffy whipped cream and a sprinkle of golden toasted coconut flakes, adding a satisfying crunch to every bite. Each forkful offers a delightful mix of creamy and crunchy textures, transporting your taste buds to paradise and making it a must-try for coconut lovers and dessert enthusiasts alike. Keep the fun going with a pie from one of Miami's other great bakeries on the full list.
Nashville - Elliston Place Soda Shop
View this post on Instagram
2105 Elliston Place / Website
For over 84 years, this neighborhood soda shop has served specialties, sodas, milkshakes and desserts. Elliston Place Soda Shop is the place to go for legendary pies handcrafted by Linda Melton, the “Pie Lady,” who has been a team member since 1993. Offerings include chocolate or coconut meringue, pecan, chess or chocolate chess, lemon ice box, banana pudding and the pie of the day. Be sure to try the other pies on Nashville's full list.
NYC - Milk Bar
View this post on Instagram
One of the city's long-time favorites, customers come again and again for Milk Bar’s extravagant creations. The signature Milk Bar pie is filled with oozing butter, cream and sugar enveloped in a toasted oat crust. We recommend grabbing some Cereal Milk soft serve to go along with your pie for the ultimate Milk Bar experience. The Big Apple has more to bite, so be sure to check the other pies on NYC's full list.
San Francisco - Three Babes Bakeshop
View this post on Instagram
Stick it to the patriarchy one slice at a time at this women- and minority-owned bake shop dealing tons of delicious baked goods. What started as a pie pop-up shop in the Mission has now become a local favorite that ships top-tier pies all across the nation. Visit the commercial kitchen for incredible edibles like classic apple and pumpkin, bourbon pecan, key lime, vegan blackberry crumble and more. The seasonal menu changes regularly, so check out the website for up-to-date info. You can even order a pie kit for home or participate in one of Three Babes Bakeshop’s virtual and year-round classes. Please note, Three Babes is closed on Mondays. If you're in the Bay Area, be sure to check the other pies on San Francisco's full list.
Silicon Valley - Nile's Pie Company
View this post on Instagram
Baked with local whole fruit and produce, Niles Pie Company's sweet and savory pies are great for any and all occasions. It's a worker-owned cooperative, so you're supporting the collective with every delicious bite. Enjoy old fashioned pumpkin pie, caramel apple pie, brown butter brand pecan pie, blueberry crumble, double chocolate espresso, mini pies called "sweetie pies," plus savory options including Autumn beef cottage pie, ratatouille pot pie, matador steak pie and more. See even more on Silicon Valley's full list.
What goes great with pie? Coffee, so check one of the best cafes across the country, too.
Photography by:
.jpg)
